From Council refusal to VCAT approval

THE BRIEF

Two best friends wanted to build townhouses side by side on The Esplanade in Torquay, designed as homes for life for them and their partners, with the accessibility their families need now and in the years ahead.

 
DATE: 2025
LOCATION: Surf Coast, VIC
CREDITS: Renders by James Stapleton

The challenge

Surf Coast Shire Council’s main concerns were the garages’ impact on the streetscape and the side setback, and neighbours raised view-sharing objections. We reviewed the impact on neighbours’ views and found it acceptable. Over six months we worked through Council’s feedback, refined the design with architect James Stapleton and made detailed submissions with strong strategic justification, recommending a balanced design response as a final compromise. Even so, Council refused the application in June 2024.


Turning a no
into a ‘yes!’

We were confident the design we had recommended to Council was an acceptable outcome, and so were our clients. They took the decision to VCAT with planning lawyers Best Hooper.


The outcome

In March 2025, VCAT directed that a planning permit be granted (VCAT reference P697/2024), with no onerous conditions. The Tribunal found the overall outcome acceptable, including on view sharing, consistent with the submissions we made to Council before its decision. Two friends can now build the homes they planned for their families.


Why it matters

Approvals have lasting impacts on people’s lives. When we believe a proposal is acceptable, we say so clearly and back it with evidence. This project is what we mean by turning a no into a yes, and the decision is a useful guide for similar proposals in Torquay and Jan Juc.


Next
Next

A beach house approved with the design intact